Letter on What Cannot Be Taken From You
On the inmost citadel — the coordinate inside you that no silence, no cool reception, no failed launch can reach.
Dear friend,
I want to write to you tonight about something I think you have not fully claimed yet. Something I think most women in this kind of work have not claimed. It is the thing that makes the work survivable, and most teaching about it is either too vague or too grand.
You are about to be visible in a way you have not been before. You are about to publish something. Open an offer page. Ask to be paid. Walk into rooms where someone might criticize you. Send messages that might be ignored. Wait for responses that might not arrive.
When you do these things, the world — or more accurately, your idea of the world — will appear to threaten you. It will appear to threaten everything you have built, including the inner sense of yourself you have spent decades constructing. The threat will not always be loud. Sometimes it will be the cool silence after you publish. Sometimes the email that does not come. Sometimes the polite half-smile at a dinner party when you mention what you are now doing.
I want to tell you tonight about what cannot be threatened.
Let me begin with what can be threatened. I will be honest with you about it, because the honesty is important.
The audience can leave. The reader can close the tab. The client can choose someone else. The market can stop responding to your particular shape of work. The reputation can be damaged. The money can dry up. The body can grow tired. The credentials can be questioned. The reception can be cool. Other people can do versions of what you do, and theirs may be more polished, more popular, faster, larger.
All of these are real. None of them are within your control. And because they are real and not within your control, they will, at various points, appear to be at risk.
Most makers, when they begin this kind of work, organize their inner life around defending these things. They worry about the audience. They protect the reputation. They strategize the market. They tend the money carefully, the way one tends a small fire. They become, slowly, custodians of an outer scaffolding that they perceive as their actual self.
And then, one day, something on the scaffolding breaks. A reader writes a cruel comment. A client leaves. A launch fails. And the maker discovers — sometimes catastrophically — that she had been resting her sense of self on something that could be taken away.
This is the first error I want to spare you from.
There is something in you that cannot be taken away. It has been there since you were a small child watching dust motes in the sun. It will be there when you are eighty, on a chair, in a garden, near the end. Nothing in any of your visible work has anything to do with it.
I want to name it precisely.
It is the place where, when nothing else is happening, you are still here. Not the part of you that is anxious about the launch. Not the part of you that is composing the next email in your mind. The part of you under all of that. The part that has been watching the anxious part. The part that, even now, while you read this sentence, is the one doing the reading — not the words on the page, but the one for whom the words are arriving.
That is the part I am writing about.
It has been named in every tradition that has ever tried to name it. The Hebrew Bible names it most precisely. When Moses asks the burning bush for a name, the bush gives an answer that has not been improved upon in three thousand years: Ehyeh asher ehyeh. I am that I am. Not I am the maker of stars. Not I am the ancient one. Just: I am that I am. The self-grounded fact of being.
You have a version of this in you. Not the cosmic version — yours is small and quiet and Bulgarian and fifty-one and yours. But it is the same kind of fact. You are. You have been being, continuously, since you arrived. The continuity is unbroken. Even in sleep, in surgery, in moments you do not remember — something persisted that lets you say, now, I was there.
This is what cannot be taken from you.
The Romans, who were practical people, called the practical version of this securitas — not security in our modern banking sense, but a kind of inner unshakeability. Seneca writes about it often. He had seen Nero up close and was about to be ordered to take his own life, and even from inside that situation he is writing letters describing what cannot be touched.
Six hundred years later, Boethius — a Roman senator imprisoned and awaiting execution for a political conviction he had not committed — wrote The Consolation of Philosophy. It is a long argument with himself about which of his losses were real losses. He concluded: Fortune can rotate her wheel as much as she likes; the wheel does not reach into the center. The center, in his term, was the inmost citadel. The wheel could take everything else. The citadel was his.
I think you have a citadel.
There is a woman in our recent history I want you to know about, if you do not already. Her name was Etty Hillesum. She was a young Dutch woman, Jewish, in her twenties, sent to the Westerbork transit camp in 1942 and then to Auschwitz in 1943, where she was murdered. Before she went, she kept a diary. Throughout her months at Westerbork — under conditions one cannot imagine — she wrote, repeatedly, a single sentence: They cannot get at this.
She was not talking about her body. They were obviously about to get at her body. She was not talking about her freedom. They had clearly already taken her freedom. She was talking about something else — something she had located in herself — that the entire apparatus of the camps and the trains and the eventual gas chambers could not reach.
She was right. She lived inside what was untouchable until the moment the body stopped. The diary survives. The inmost citadel, in her case, was kept open until the end.
I am not going to compare your ordinary mortal launch-fears to Auschwitz. The comparison would be obscene. I bring up Etty Hillesum because she located, in the most extreme conditions a human being can be in, the same coordinate I am asking you to locate in your ordinary middle-class life. The coordinate is the same. The pressure on it is incomparable. But the coordinate is the same.
If she could find it there, you can find it here.
What does it feel like, this coordinate?
It feels like four things. I want to give you them as a small phrase you can return to.
Not alone. Not empty. Not isolated. And most alive.
When you are in the place I am describing, you are not alone — even if no one else is in the room — because the place itself is participatory. Something attends. Something is also present.
You are not empty — even if your day has been hard and your hollowness is up — because the place is the opposite of hollow. The place is what makes hollowness recognizable as hollowness; the place is the standard against which the rest is measured.
You are not isolated — even if the audience has not yet arrived, even if the email did not come back — because the place is the place from which connection becomes possible. The connection is not what produces the place. The place is what makes connection possible at all.
And — perhaps the most important — you are most alive. The aliveness of this place is not produced by external events. It is the constant low pulse underneath everything. Most lives almost never visit it. Yours, if you do this work well, will spend years sitting in it.
What does this do, practically?
It does this. You can write the essay without depending on the response to it for your sense of self. You can publish, and if no one responds, the inner coordinate is unchanged. You can open the offer page, and if no one buys, the inner coordinate is unchanged. You can hear the cruel comment, and the inner coordinate is unchanged.
This sounds austere. It is not austere. It is the opposite. It is what allows you to write with warmth, because the warmth does not have to be returned for the writing to be worth doing. It is what allows you to offer service with full presence, because the service does not depend on the client’s approval for its meaning. It is what allows you to make the work without armoring yourself.
The takers in this market never find this place. They cannot. Their entire stance is organized around getting something from the audience — money, attention, validation, signed contracts. They are, by structural necessity, dependent on outcomes. Their inner coordinate is wherever the audience says it is.
The carer, by contrast, has located her coordinate inside herself, and the audience is then free to be whatever it is. Some days that is many people. Some days that is no one. Either way, the carer is in the same place, doing the same work, in the same body. The audience changes; she does not.
This is also why the carer can do this work for forty years without burning out. There is nothing to burn. The fuel is not external validation. The fuel is what cannot be threatened in the first place. It does not run out. It cannot be drained.
This is also why no one can steal your work, in any meaningful sense.
Other people may borrow your phrases. They may use your method without credit. They may build offers that resemble yours, sometimes very closely. None of this can reach the coordinate I am describing. The coordinate is not the work. The coordinate is the place from which you produce the work. Anyone can borrow the work. No one can borrow the coordinate, because the coordinate is yours and is not portable.
This means: do not spend any of your finite life energy defending the work against being borrowed. Spend it on staying inside the coordinate, doing the next piece of work, from the place where the work originates. The next piece is also yours, because it will be made from the same place. The place is what makes the work distinctive. Not the words. The location.
A woman who has located this coordinate writes in a voice that cannot be replicated, because the voice is the sound of this specific coordinate, vibrating into language. Even if someone tries to imitate the words, they will be saying them from a different coordinate, and the ear will know.
I want to close, as Rilke did, with one small practical thing.
When you become aware, tomorrow or the day after, that something outside you is appearing to threaten what you are doing — a silence, a cool response, a cruel comment, a comparison to another maker — I want you to remember the four words.
Not alone. Not empty. Not isolated. And most alive.
Say them, quietly, in the room where you are. Notice that they are still true. The reception in the outer world has not changed them. The coordinate is still here.
Then go back to the work.
This is what cannot be stolen from you. This is what no taker can reach. This is the inmost citadel, the burning bush’s I am, Etty Hillesum’s they cannot get at this. It has always been yours. It is still yours, in this moment, while you read.
Please make a home in it.
With love, and across centuries of women who have known this,
— I.